logo

Home

Furniture Gallery


Newsletter Sign Up
Newsletter Archives

Individually Styled and Crafted

Fine Hardwood Furniture

by

Andrew Pitts ~ FurnitureMaker

Work in Progress
Persimmon Shelving Unit with Drawers

Article Completed 21 December 2009



Disclaimer: This discussion chronicles the making of a piece of furniture in my workshop. My intention is to bring the reader virtually into my shop to generally see how I do the work and share in my thought processes. Although I try to point out how the tools work and the applicable safety considerations, this discussion is not intended to be a text on how to work with tools, nor how to execute operations with the tools shown. I am not providing instruction in woodworking methods. Woodworkers attempting to imitate my methods do so at their own risk.

Click on images to enlarge and see details


Rendering


             Today is 16 September. Back in mid-February I received a call asking me if I would be interested in milling a fallen tree and making a piece of furniture from the lumber. The tree was a Persimmon. I have to admit that I knew nothing about persimmon at the time, but this is the kind of project I like, so I made an appointment to see the tree. When I arrived I found a very large persimmon tree that had a bit of decay, but otherwise looked sound. ILogs on trailer had done some research and discovered that persimmon is from the same family as ebony and shared some characteristics, so it could be fabulous wood. I also learned that persimmon is a difficult wood to dry and that I could expect some degradation, such as cracking, during drying. We decided to give it a shot, and if during milling it looked like the tree would not yield sound lumber we could call it quits at that point. So, with trailer in tow, I went to the site to recover the logs. Fortunately, my client owns a tractor, so Persimmon plankwith his tractor and my trailer winch we got the logs onto the trailer. The photo at right shows just how large the two log sections were. A few days later I set up to mill the logs. I wanted to get them into the kiln right away for a couple of reasons. First, I wanted to arrest any further decay by drying the lumber below the point where decay thrives. But, I wanted the drying to be slow, and a solar kiln in the middle of winter dries really, really slow! During the milling, my clients visited to watch the process, which can be pretty exciting, especially when your log is opened for the first time. In the photo at left you can see just how nice the wood looked on the mill.kiln charge Immediately after milling I charged the solar kiln with the lumber - often I will air dry the lumber for a while, Best woodbut as I mentioned, I wanted to kiln it right away. The photo to the right shows the charge in the kiln, along with some red oak I milled at the same time. The oak in the kiln afforded the advantage of providing some heat sink so that the kiln would not heat up too much during the day. The more lumber in the kiln, the more there is to heat up during the few hours my kiln receives direct sunlight so the maximum kiln temperature will be lower before the sun goes behind the trees. It took until early June for the wood to dry to the 7-8% moisture content necessary for furniture kept indoors around here. When I removed the wood it looked good, for the most part. I would still have to work around a lot of cracks, but I assessed that we would be able to build a piece of furniture with it! The photo at left shows the best pieces of all the lumber, and you can see where the tie to ebony comes in.

             With the wood dried and inspected, I set upon the design phase. As usual, I provided three fairly radically different design ideas to help my client home in on the right one, and after some iterations with drawings (all sent by e-mail, as I use Computer Aided Design (CAD) and can make renderings like the one at the beginning of this article) we settled upon the design. I could see that the piece would be big and heavy - it is six feet tall and nearly seven feet long - so I asked my client if I could check all the door measurements at the house to make sure the piece would fit. It had to go through double doors and immediately turn left and ascend a flight of stairs. I had estimated that the lightest I could make the piece, partially disassembled would exceed 300 pounds. I would have a better idea of weight after I had the opportunity to calculate the density of the wood. Using my CAD program I actually made a quick drawing of the door, the stairs, and the walls enclosing them and then manipulated the 3-D drawing of the piece through the door, around the corner, and up the stairs. Now I am sure the piece will fit and we only have to find some REALLY BIG GUYS to move it up the stairs and into the room it would occupy.

             The persimmon planks were quite wide - about 14 inches, and I needed to flatten them efficiently early in the construction process. I had been thinking of buying a 16 inch wide jointer for some time, and this was the impetus to finally break down and do it. I researched all the options and settled on a machine and ordered it. The machine shipped by motor freight (trailer truck), and since it would be really tough for a trailer truck to make it up to my shop and I had real doubts about my ability to pick up the load from the back of the truck with my tractor and that is if the driver could even get the machine to the back of the truck - it weighed over 1800 lbs crated - I made the prudent decision to take my flatbed trailer to Richmond to pick up the machine at the freight terminal. Easier said than done. I thought I had a pretty good idea of how to get around Richmond. After all, I lived there for six months in 1970. How much could have changed? Ahem .... lots! I think I discovered all the worst back roads south of the James trying to get over to the Midlothian
Big box Turnpike, but I made it. After they loaded the big box onto my trailer using a big fork lift, I asked for directions home. I think the directions must have been pretty good, if I had actually taken them, but a wrong turn early in the homebound trip sent me through some of the nicest parts of west Richmond, but unfortunately not the best way to go with a 17 ft trailer and a heavy load. jointerLesson learned - just stay put here on the Northern Neck whenever possible, and when I do have to travel afar, don't forget to bring a map! When I got home, I could barely pick up the big box with my tractor (take a look at the box on the tractor at right), but I managed to get it into the shop and onto the new cement slab I had poured this spring. It took several days to uncrate, move, electrically wire, and hook up dust collection for the machine, but it looks pretty good in the shop, now and I am ready to make wide boards flat.

             The first part of the piece to make would be the left side that is a curved piece six feet tall. I would have to bandsaw layers of persimmon and laminate them to layers of poplar to make the side, and this would require a curved form to bend the layers around. The form would go into a vacuum bag with a couple of layers inside and with glue between them, then I would seal the bag and evacuate it. The atmospheric pressure on the bag would clamp
the layers together. I would repeat this process until the proper thickness was achieved. Now, the area of the top and bottom of the form would be about 1900 square inches, each. My vacuum pump can draw about 25 inches of mercury vacuum, equating to a pressure ofForm bottom about 12.5 pounds per square inch. So, the top would see a total force of 12.5 psi x 1900 sq in = 23,750 pounds, or about 12 tons. The bottom of the form would see the same force, so the forces would equalize. However, the form itself would have toForm inside withstand these 12 tons of force without crushing. Hmmm ... 12 tons ... that's about six Volkswagens! The sides would see great force, as well, more like 2-1/2 tons. Better make the form strong! The photo at right shows the form upside down, and you can make out the bottom and routing to templatethe ribs. The photo beneath shows the form flipped right side up. The way I made all the ribs the same was to make one exactly right then use it as a template to form with a straight bit in my router, as seen in the photo to left.  I added some cross ribs between the outer most ribs and the next ribs in, and then onto the ribs I screwed two layers of 1/4 inch plywood as seen at left. I put this form Form sheathedinto the bag for a dry run, and when the vacuum got to about half-way, the form started creaking. At three quarters vacuum it creaked enough that I dropped the vacuum, removed the form from the bag, and put a lot more screws into it. Then I tried again and made full vacuum, leaving the form under vacuum for several hours. No crushing! Now I am ready to actually glue up some laminations.

sorting lumber
                With the form made and tested I set upon making the laminate layers for the side. First, I sorted out all the persimmon to resawing persimmondecide which plank would go where, and in the photo at right you can see my jointer room clobbered with all the planks. It made walking around tough!  I decided upon a plank that I could resaw into thin strips, but since thatsanding laminate strips particular plank had damage in the core I ripped it into two smaller planks, jointed a face flat, and then resawed it into strips about 3/16" thick on the bandsaw, as seen at left. My objective was to get 1/8" thick strips after sanding them to thickness on the horizontal drum sander, as seen at right. I used 100 grit paper, since that is a good roughness for gluing. Fortunately, I ended up with enough wood to laminate both faces of the large curved side piece. Next, I decided upon the veneer layout. This process was easier said than done, and it took me a while to get it right. Here's the problem; I was veneering both sides of the curved core, and I wanted the inside grain pattern to match, as much as possible, the outside pattern so it would appear as though you were looking at a single curved plank of wood. Now, with the shop cut veneer I was using here my best hope was to at least get the match close, and knowing that nobody could actually see both sides of the plank at one time I took advantage of that fact. Additionally, I was planning to book match the strips as much as possible, and at the same time work around the defects. I tried and retried differentVeneer layout combinations until I had the grain patterns optimized, then carefully planed the edges of the veneer and laid them up on a large table, temporarily taping them in place relative to one another using blue masking tape, the kind that pulls off easily. When I was convinced that I had both side's veneers correct, I used veneer tape to assemble the pieces, taping on the unglued side (the show face) of the veneer, as seen at right. Veneer tape is very thin paper tape that has a water Taped veneeractivated adhesive, like on the flap of an envelope. As the tape dries on the wood, it shrinks a little and helps pull the joint tight so when the veneer is glued to the substrate it will appear to have no glue line, or at least that is the objective. The photo at left shows the concave face veneer taped up into a panel. I've got to add that with an asymmetric panel like this, I really have to keep my situational awareness about the orientation of the veneers. If I got confused, I would tape up the pieces as a mirror image of how they should be, and if not caught before gluing, the intended show face would actually become the glue face. But this day I was not confused, and the layout looked good. Next came the making of the core for the panel. The chosen wood was tulip poplar because it is plentiful, economical, tight grained, and easy to work with. The reason I used solid wood for the core was twofold. First, I wanted to ensure that the panel would shrink and swell seasonally similarly to the shelves, so keeping grain orientations the same was paramount. I had thought of using 1/4" plywood for the core layers, which certainly would have been less expensive than making the core layers from planks, but a plywood core would beResawing core laminate exceptionally stable and resist the movement of the shelves mortised into it, making for danger of cracking of the shelves during the winter when the heat is on and the air inside the house gets really dry. Secondly, although the edges of the panel would be ebonized (stained black), I still wanted to retain a grain texture on the edge and plywood would have to be filled and smoothed, lest it look like plywood. So, although the poplar grain is tighter than the persimmon grain, it was still a good compromise to use poplar. If I had an unlimited supply of persimmon, I would have simply use that for the core, but my supply was pretty tight for the job. I first had to selectPlaning laminates the poplar planks, face one side on that nice new big jointer, and then resaw the planks into pieces a bit shy of 3/8" thick, as seen at right. I went for 3/8" because the bandsaw leaves marks that have to be planed or sanded away to achieve a final thickness of 1/4". Since 1/4" is thick enough to use the planer, and the planer is far superior to the drum sander for thicknessing I was able to use my 15" planer to do the job, as seen at left. For those not familiar with the planer, it has a rotating drum with 15" long knives (sharpened like a very wide hand plane blade) that cuts the top ofStacked laminates the plank as feed rollers move the plank along a machined table. This little Makita 2040 planer, no longer made, is sweet and does a nice job. With the laminates planed to thickness, I took a light cut on the drum sander to roughen the surface for glue and then started the layout to get layers in the same shape as the veneers. I had to stager the joints so that the seven layers of poplar would glue up to a strong panel, and I wanted the joints fairly tight as well. The photo to right shows all seven layers on my saw table. Now came the hairy part - the glue-up. The plan was to use Unibond 800 resin glue to make a total of seven poplar and two persimmon layers into a big sandwich. Of the seven poplar layers, only four were full height. The last three layers were cut progressively shorter so that after gluing them I could smooth what would be the inside, convex face of the panel before attaching the inside veneer. That would give the panel it's thicker at the bottom than at the top look. I was unsure of how the gluing would go, and because I have to work fast and get the work clamped before the glue sets I decided toVacuum bagging keep it simple and glue only the bottom veneer and the first layer of poplar core. As it turns out, that was a good move because I had some difficulty keeping all the parts aligned and got the assembly finally clamped just in time. These kind of glue ups are a real sweat exercise! The photo at right shows the work on the form and in the vacuum bag with the opening of the bag clamped shut. You can also see the vacuum pump off to the right. It is a venturi pump, using compressed air to draw a vacuum and I can achieve about 25 inches of vacuum, or about 12.5 psi pressure on the work. I learned some lessons with that first glue up, and in the second glue up I also attached two additional layers of poplar, although this time there were actually two glue layers to contend with.
Power planing
             It took several days to glue all the layers, and when it was done I set upon smoothing the convex inside face of the laminate. First, I set up the piece on saw horses outside and used my power planer to rough shape the side. The power planer is like an upside down jointer, but small, only 3" wide, and portable. A motor spins the drum with the blade and the planer is fed into the stock. It cuts very quickly, so I have to be careful that I don't take off too much stock while smoothing the steps of the last three, shorter layers of poplar. The photo at right shows me using the power planer outside. Why outside? It's because the power planer spits shavings all over the place, and it is easier to sweep them into the plant beds below the deck than to clean up my shop. Besides, it's good mulch. By the way, sorry about the coloration of the photo - with the sun out there was aPlaning side lot of contrast between the work, which was in the shade, and the bright deck behind. After power planing, which is just a rough shaping, I brought the piece inside and clamped it to my bench. Then I used a smooth plane and then a jack plane to really smooth it and make it truly flat across the board and with a smooth continuous curve, as seen at right. A smooth plane is what you normally think of as a hand plane, and a jack plane is just a longer version. I like to use low angle planes, where the blade sits at a lower angle than in a conventional plane. If you are interested in why, shoot me an e-mail and we can talk. While I planed I noticed a curious thing. The side seemed to be bowed up slightly across the plank at the lower (thicker) end. Now, I knew that the form was true, and I knew that the laminates were all the same thickness, so why the bow? Hmmmm.... here's my theory. I am vacuum clamping, and at this point I had gone through four iterations, adding layers as I went. That means the bottom two layers saw the vacuum four times, usually over night, so they were under vacuum for something like 48 hours. The next two layers for 36 hours, etc. In a vacuum, the partial pressures of gases in the atmosphere (a vacuum) are zero, since there are no gases in a vacuum, while the gases inside the wood, and that means potential water vapor from the moisture in the wood, have what we would call a normal partial pressure exhibited before the wood went into the vacuum bag. So, there is a natural diffusion of the water vapor out of the wood (we call that drying) and into the vacuum in an attempt to equalize the partial pressures inside and outside of the wood. When the pressures Side planedinside and outside equalize, there is no more diffusion. But, my vacuum pump keeps pulling any gases inside the bag out, so the pressures of the gases inside and outside the wood can never equalize and drying goes on and on. I think the layers that were under vacuum for the longest dried the most, and that means they shrinked more than the next couple of layers, etc. This naturally put stresses on the piece between pairs of layers, such that the concave side, or the first layers glued, tried to shrink more than the next layers, etc. Additionally, the bottom layers can dry out more easily because the glue between layers acts as a barrier to water diffusion, so possibly the bottom layers continued to dry with each clamping, while the inner layers could not dry as fast. Of course, my theory could be completely bogus! The bottom line, though, was that the plank was not flat from side to side, so I planed it almost flat. If you take a look at the photo at left, you may notice the horizontal "lines", four of them, that show the junction of the short layers to the layers below. You can see that the lines are kind of U-shaped, especially the bottom most line. That is what happens when I plane more at the center than at the edges in an attempt to flatten the plank from side to side. I hope that after all the clamping is complete, the plank will settle down and partially return to a shape where the face is truly flat from side to side. for that reason, I left a little of the bow in the plank. As a last resort, the final layer is a 1/8" persimmon veneer, and with such a thick veneer I can do a little touch up with a plane to make sure the surfaces that will accept the shelves are nice and flat.
Vacuum bagging second curved side
                Once the first, largest side was completely glued into a laminate, I broke down the form and reshaped the ribs for the next side piece, which would be at the top right side of the shelves. Reusing the ribs from the largest side saved a lot of MDF, and I could repeat the procedure for the shortest side, the right bottom side.  The photo at right shows the vacuum bagging of the shelf side so you can see what I mean.

                As you can imagine, gluing up these sides consumed a number of days as the glue dried, so in the mean time I started to select and cut the long shelving lumber. This piece has a wide and long bottom plank, which was the most challenging to make up and keep flat. The
Cutting to lengthtotal width of the bottom approached 24 inches, and none of the persimmon was near wide enough for that. Additionally, since the persimmon dried so wildly, I found that I had to make the bottom from four narrow slabs in order to maximize its thickness. The original plan called for a bottom 1-1/2 inches thick, but I had milled all the lumber to 5/4 (1-1/4+ inches). I realized that I would either modify the plan for a 1 inch thick bottom, or make up a filler piece to glue to the underside of the front of the bottom toPlaning bottom plank give the illusion of thickness. I'm still thinking about that. In the mean time, I sawed the lumber to length using a portable circular saw, as shown at left. This is a really messy operation, so I do it downstairs alongside the big jointer. I have to open the garage door and cut outside, or if it is raining turn on a fan to blow the dust outside. But, at this point the planks are kind of wild as they twist and bend, so I cannot saw them on a stationary machine. I have to wait until the pieces are cut more to final size before I mill them on the jointer and planer, or rip them on the cabinet saw. But, when they are manageable I joint and plane them better to size. At right, I am planing a slab of the bottom on a 20 inch planer. The bottom, although the largest of the shelf pieces, is also the least visible, so I did not worry about grain orientation and simply made up the wide slab from the four most straight pieces I could. In the end, I glued up the four pieces and the bottom is nice and true.
Bandsaw splitting of top
             The top shelf was a different challenge. It, too, was long, but at 13 inches was not nearly as wide as the bottom. I could make Jointing shelvesthe top from a single plank, but here the grain mattered. I selected the clearest piece of lumber I could, but it dried with a severe cup, and had I flattened it on the jointer and planer I would have lost a lot of thickness. The solution was to rip the plank lengthwise, joint and plane the two pieces flat, then edge the pieces so they could be reglued toJointing top edge make the plank look almost like it did before ripping, but flat! The photo at right shows me ripping the plank on the bandsaw, which made a thin kerf so little of the grain was lost. Then the pieces were flattened on the jointer, similar to the way I used the jointer at left. Then I planed the pieces like I did with the bottom in the photo above, and when they were nice and flat I Dry fit topedged them on the jointer as seen at right. By running the two pieces along the fence on their opposite faces I was able to cancel out any error from 90 degrees in the fence angle and end up with pieces that fit together to make a flat panel. The photo at left shows the pieces sitting together, before gluing, and you would be hard pressed to tell that you are actually looking at two pieces of wood. After glueup it was near impossible to tell. It is importantDomino top edge to make sure that the two pieces lay along exactly the same plane when glued, and for this insurance I decided to use small dominos as tenons about every foot along the length. These tenons don't add any strength to the joint, but they do an outstanding job of registering the two pieces so the end glueup is almost flat and requires little additional planing. The photo at right shows me using the Domino tenon machine to cut the mortises in the edge of the top pieces. By the way, I used this same technique to register the four pieces of the bottom before gluing. I made the shelves without having to rip the halves apart, except for the tops of the drawers, the pieces that form the two "countertops", which were cupped so badly that they required this procedure.
marking edge
             After the gluing of the side laminates was complete, I was able to refocus my attention on continuing to shape them. At this point the three laminated pieces were nicely formed in the curve, but the back, front, top, and bottom edges were very rough. I first trued up the back edges and used that as a reference for cutting the otherSawing curved edge edges correctly. The back edges were the only ones that were to be straight and true. On the long side I had to use the circular saw to true the edge, and to mark the cut line I used a thin strip of wood and clamped it to the piece to mark along with a pencil, seen at right. Again, sawing was a dusty operation, and I was also afraid of small, sharp pieces of wood and glue flying into my face, so I doned a full face mask to make the cut, as seen at right. On the smaller sides I used a cabinet saw to true up the back edge. With the back edges true, I cut the top and bottom edges to the Saber sawing curvecorrect angles so when the sides were set vertically the top and bottom edges would be horizontal.spokeshave edge To figure out the correct bevel angle for the saw (the dusty circular saw), I propped up one end while the side was on the bench, concave face down. I had already used my CAD program to figure out how far to prop up the pieces, so I simply measured the correct bevel angle for the saw while the sides were propped up. Cutting the curved front edge required sketching the curve (again, using cues from the CAD program to mark the surface of the wood) and then using a saber saw to cut the curve, as seen at left. I finished up by using a spokeshave to fair in the curve nicely, as seen at right.

             The next operation in the critical path was to make the back. The back was to fit within the sides and the top and bottom shelves, so making it at this point had the advantage of creating an actual template, the back itself, for assembling the sides and shelves. If I could get the sides to fit snugly to the back, the shelves could be cut to the exact length to fit into the sides. The back was to be a simple frame and panel back similar to those I've made on other pieces, where the panels do not intersect the frame on the sides, but instead there is a small gap between the frame and the panels, as well as between panels. Take a look at this link to the back of my "Special Cabinet" to see what I mean. I selected the best wood I could for the back pieces, since the back would be very visible in the front view, then rough cut the frame pieces and panels to size. I deliberated on exactly what pieces to use for the panels, and ended up using different planks than what I originally had intended. The reason was that I wanted to book match the six main panels and I needed the pieces to be wide. I selected three planks from
Butterfly the section of the tree just below the main crotch, where the grain was a bit wild but the planks were anything but flat. In order to do the bookmatching from the 5/4 lumber (nominally 1-1/4" thick), considering the warpage in the planks, I knew that if I could end up with a finished panel thickness of 3/8" I would be doing OK. The panels had some cracks in them, so after thicknessing and trimming them Rotex sanderalmost exactly to size, I made up some butterflies to seam up some of the larger cracks. These butterflies, which were hour glass shaped pieces of walnut, would hold the cracks together, as seen in the photo at right. Aside from the structural attributes, butterflies add some interesting accents to an otherwise plain surface. You may have noticed the lower part of the piece is wider than the top, so I needed a 7th panel down there. For this I made up a single bookCutting slots matched panel from some figured persimmon, seen at left (I'm sanding it with my Festool Rotex sander, a really nice tool). With the panels roughly made, I worked on the frame mortises that the panels would fit into. I decided to use a 5/16" end mill bit to make a 5/16" slot, 1/2" deep for each panel. Then I would shave away 1/32" from each Trimming backside of the panels at the last 1/2" of the ends to make 5/16" tenon ends. The photo at right shows a frame piece on the router table and if you look closely you can see the 5/16" end mill bit in the router (click on the photo to enlarge it). Also, in the photo you can see some of the mortises that will hold the frame together. Those were made with the Domino machine. The photo at left shows the same router table being used with a rabbeting bit to shave the 1/32" from the last 1/2" of the panel to make the tenon end. Notice the auxiliary fence I made to keep the bit away from my fingers and provide a fence for guiding the work. The cut could be made using theLayout bearing on the bit to guide the work, but the aux fence is much safer. With all the machining done, I needed to make the back fit nicely into the sides, so I needed to trace the actual curvature of the sides onto the back frame and then cut the pieces on the bandsaw before gluing up the back. So, I dry assembled the entire back and set the side pieces onto the back to trace the curves, as seen at right. At this point I was really only interested in the frame fitup, but the panels were just laid on top of the frame to check the look of the grain.

                The finishing of any nice wood requires a lot of hand work, and here was no exception. At right I am
Card scraper using a card scraper to remove some saw marks from a piece of the frame. A card scraper is a thin card shaped piece of spring steel, typically something like 3" x 5" or so (but it can be shaped to a curve, as well) that is sharpened and used in a unique way. Instead of sharpening to a chisel like edge that is pushed into the wood to slice it, the scraper is first ground with a perfect 90 degree edge, then using a burnisher (a bar of steel), the corner of the edge is "pushed" over to form a small burr, or hook of steel. Then the card is held a few degrees from vertical, flexed with the fingers and thumbs, and is pushed along the wood. The burr cuts a minuscule shaving, which curls away from the wood. The scraper can be used in any grain direction - it will not tear out unruly grain, and that is the strength of the tool. Rather than chance tearing grain with a hand plane, the scraper makes quick work of small defects and results in a surface that requires only very fine sanding, like P400 grit or finer. By the way, as kind of a tool junkie I own a nice cabinet scraper and a scraper plane, which are nice holders for scraper blades to make surfaces really flat. But, maybe because I learned with a Thinner wipesimple card scraper in the first place I get better results with the simpler tool and find myself always reaching for it. I have developed a good feel for when the card scraper is cutting right, and know how to tune it up for the best cuts. The only real downfall to the card scraper is that it gets very hot in use, and my thumbs, in close proximity to the cutting edge are the victims of that heat. Ouch! After planing, scraping, and sanding, I checked the surface for scratches by applying some mineral spirits (paint thinner) to the wood, as seen at left. Any scratches will show up while the surface is wet. In addition, the mineral spirits will raiseBack clamp up the grain to the extent that any spirit based finish will (which is not much), and since it was decided to use an oil/varnish/beeswax finish, a quick sanding before finishing is all that will be required. Finally, with all the parts machined and sanded, I glued up the back. First I glued the bottom frames, let them set up well, and then glued up the top frame to the bottom. The photo at right shows the final glue up, with the assembly on the shop floor and my longest bar clamps to bring the mortise and tenon joints home.

                All the work to this point was the easy stuff. Now, I had to figure out how to make through mortises in the sides and tenons on the ends of the shelves and drawer carcases. A through tenon is where a tenon is cut on the end of a shelf and it extends all the way through a mortise in the side so the end of the tenon is visible. Take a look at the rendering at the top of this essay and you will notice the dark spots on the curved sides - these are the ends of the through tenons. I always cut a slot or two in the end of the tenon and make up wedges of contrasting colored wood to drive into the slots. These wedges spread the tenon sides to fit very firmly in the mortise, and they look cool. Even with very precise machine-cut through mortise and tenon joints, the wedges add a lot to the final look. Now, I cannot emphasize too much that this was to be a BIG piece of furniture. Add to the massive size the fact that the sides were curved, and what would have been a straight forward operation with a flat sided cabinet was now complicated by a large factor. I had to make sure the mortises cut into the curved sides would be axially in line with the shelves so that when the shelves were joined to the sides the angle betweenLayout shelves shelf and side would be correct. The first step was to do a very accurate layout and ensure all the angles would be correct. The photo at right shows my setup. I took four saw horses and set two old doors on them (my house's former front doors), shimming the doors until I had a planer surface. Then, I set the newly glued up back onto the doors, and then set the sides on edge along the back in the same configuration they would be in for the finished piece. If I had cut the back edges of the sides true and flat, it would be a simple matter of laying out lines where all the shelves would fit so I would have an accurate picture of where the mortises had to be cut. Well, at this point I was able to discover some inaccuracies in the trueness of the back edges of the sides and I corrected them with a hand plane. Now, with the sides vertical and the back horizontal and the orientation correct, I marked on the back the position of each shelf and then used a framing square to draw vertical lines on the sides showing the line of the mortises. Finally, I used a long straight edge and connected the tops of the lines I had just drawn so I could draw lines across the edges to the outside of the sides, these lines being coaxial with the mortises. I compared these lines to those calculated with my CAD program to make sure they were close to what I had predicted. Once I was satisfied that the layout for the mortises was correct, I contemplated how to cut the mortises, themselves. Now, there are lots of ways to cut mortises, but in all the 'how to' books the mortises are being cut in nice square and relatively small stock, not in immense and curved laminations. Was I crazy to design a piece like this, or what? I had hoped that I would have a revelation before this point on how to cut the mortises, but now I was against the wall. I could not simply use a chisel and guide block to chop the mortises, because what is square, here? None of my conventional methods would work, either. Well, I won't bore you with all my thinking on this, but if you watched Dr. Shepherd on Grey's Anatomy spend 26 hours in the operating room staring at a tumor trying to figure out how to operate on it, you get the picture of what my workshop looked like when I was figuring out how to cut these mortises. Fortunately for my client, I stopped the billing clock during these long deliberations - it would be unfair to charge them for my insanity in designing such a complex piece of furniture! What I finally came up with would be accurate and doable. I would use a drill press with Forstner bits to drill out holes, the diameters of which would be the same as the dimensions of the mortises. Forstner bits are special drill bits that cut a hole straight and true, even if the surface the bit is entering is not square to the direction of the bit travel. Then, with a corner chisel (a chisel cut with a 90Through mortise degree angle between faces, like a corner) I would "simply" square up the holes I had cut. Easy! (not!). To get the angle of entry of the bit correct, I would have to shim the work until the lines I had drawn were coaxial with the travel of the bit in the drill press. Here, I Mortise long sidecould compare the amount of shimming necessary against the CAD calculation to double check the setup. In the photo at right, I am drilling the mortise holes in the shortest side piece, and you can see the shimmingChopping mortises arrangement. The far end of the work is sitting on a block of wood, raising it until the bit enters at the right angle. The photo at left shows the same thing with the longest side, which due to it's length had to be shimmed on a table made from my saw offcut roller stands with planks stacked across them. Amazingly, this all worked! Now all I had to do was get out the corner chisel and go to work. So, after marking exactly where the chisel cuts would go (it was critical to have the mortises square so the tenons would fit exactly), I began chopping mortises as seen at right. As I said, for most of the mortises I used a corner chisel to make sure the corners were square. Then I would come back with a bench chisel to clean up the mortises. It was critical that the holes be square, especially on the outside face where they would be visible. If I did not keep the holes nice and even through the wood, that was not a big problem, but that outside face was a bigee.

                I spent hours laying out and chopping mortises, and when that was all done I spent hours laying out the tenons on the shelves. With the
Open MT mortises cut, the tenons were marked to fit exactly into the mortises. I used a marking knife to make exact lines where the tenons would be so that they would fit right. Especially critical were the "open" tenons where the short lower side intersected the short right side shelf that formed the top of the upper right drawer pocket. If this mortise and tenon joint was sloppy, it would look it in the finished piece. So, I carefully cut the joint and dry fit the pieces, with a considerable amount of tweeking with chisels and files to get the fit exact. At right you can see the dry fit joint. After gluing the joint, I will trim off the excess tenon material and make the faces flush. This particular joint did not get wedges, as all the through tenons received, so there was no room for error. However, with the through tenonsSawing tenon I would be installing two vertical wedges per tenon, so if the tenon was a hair wide or narrow, the wedging action would correct that. At left I am using a Bosch saber saw to cut the tenons. I had marked the tenons with a knife, and I am 'splitting' the knife line with the edge of the saw blade. That is actually easier than it sounds and is critical to a well fitting joint. Instead of trying to cut a pencil line, which is a thick line, I get one side of the saw kerf to split the knife line. In this case I am using a Lenox C450S blade, 10 teeth per inch in my Bosch saw. This blade has extremely little set in the teeth, if any, which means that the teeth are not alternately bent to one side or the other as in most saws. This is great if a very smooth and exact cut is desired, although it does not cut as fast as a blade with less teeth per inch and a lot of set. I was quite surprised how exact I could make the cuts with this setup. I did have to check that the blade was exactly perpendicular to the shoe of the saber saw, though. For a smaller job I would use a hand saw, a Japanese pull saw to cut the tenons, or use a setup on the table saw, but these shelves were immense so I had to bring the saw to the work and use power! As well as cutting the tenons, I also cut two kerfs in each tenon 1/4" from each of the sides for the wedges.

            
Next came the hard part ... getting all the parts to fit together correctly! Cutting mortises and tenons to plan works well for smaller pieces, and only a small amount of 'fitting' is required. But, these parts were massive and the sides were curved - there would be a lot of trial and error to make theParing tenon pieces fit together seamlessly. First, though, I had to cut a small rabbet on the top and bottom of each shelf tenon so that the mortises would not be at all visible on the inside of the cabinet. The photo at right shows me using a chisel to pare away material on the top of a tenon. I did the same on the bottom of the tenon so that the tenon height was a little less than the shelf thickness. I had to do this for Dry fitupall the tenons, and there were lots of them. For a smaller cabinet this operation could easily be done on the table saw, but for a six foot long shelf, holding it vertically while guiding it on edge through the saw, or using a dado blade to do the work horizontally seemed just a little dangerous. The price of big work! After paring the tenons to size I dry fit each joint and made little cuts here and there to get the fit smooth and as tight as I could. Then I assembled the whole carcase dry, that is, without glue, to check the fit and make marks for the shelf supports. I know this sounds easy here, but this was days of work to get done correctly. The photo at left shows the dry fitup with the shelves propped into the correct relative positions. Note that the shelvesShelf mounting were all cantilevered, that is, each was only mortised into one side. The other side, at the center of the carcase hung from the top shelf via a support structure. This support structure was a series of short vertical boards, each cut to fit between adjacent shelves. One end of the support would be screwed into a shelf and the other endInstalling wedges in tenon doweled. That way, I could install the shelves starting at the uppermost shelf and work down. The photo at right shows the first shelf installed with the support for the second shelf clamped in place after gluing the dowels. By sequentially installing shelf, then support, I build the shelf structure from the top down. Of course, all the tenons had to be wedged as I installed each shelf. In theFlush trim tenon photo at left I am installing a wedge (walnut looked best) into one of the kerfs I had cut in a tenon. After the glue on the wedges dried, I used a flush cut saw to trim the mortise flush with the sides, as seen at right. A flush cut saw has it's teeth set on only one side, the side away from the surface, so the surface is protected from becoming scratched. One of the difficult parts (OK, it was all difficult) was drawing the sides to the bottom two shelfs tightly. These shelfs were full width, six feet long, and with curved sides there was no way to clamp the opposite side together to make the joints tight. My solution was to drill holes for screws to pull the sides onto the shelves, then plug the screw holes with plugs cut from scraps of persimmon. This method worked very well, and I left the screws in place to give even more strength to the joints (as if they needed toCompleted carcase be stronger). I could hardly see the plugs after trimming them and sanding. Speaking of sanding, I guess I should mention that I sanded each part before assembly and I spent what seemed like days with my Festool Rotex sander bringing the surfaces to P320 smoothness. The Rotex is a random orbital sander with an additional setting for action more like a conventional disc sander. With the shelves all glued in place, I screwed the back on and plugged the screw holes. The screws went in through the top shelf and up through the bottom shelf, with a pair of screws directly through the back into the upper drawer opening tops. The photo at right shows the final glued up carcase. Next, the drawers.

             While I built the drawers, I put a finish on the carcase. The edges of the curved laminations were stained with dark walnut aniline dye to turn them dark brown. Aniline dye is the most light fast of the wood dies, and is easily blended to achieve correct colors. Before applying this water based dye, the wood needed to be wet with water and then sanded to cut off the raised grain that water always produces. Then the dye was applied and wiped to an even coloration. After the dye was dry, it was time to rub in the oil finish on the carcase. It takes days and weeks to cure the oil/varnish/beeswax mix I use, so getting the finish on early would help. The finish was applied in two major steps. First, a mixture of equal parts of boiled linseed oil, tung oil, and polyurethane varnish was brushed on the surfaces liberally, allowed to soak in and start to cure, then rubbed in a bit before wiping off the excess. For this piece I applied two coats this way, allowing a couple of days between coats for curing to take place. Then, I applied three coats of a mixture of boiled linseed oil, tung oil, and a handfull of beeswax melted into the mix. This mix was simply rubbed in, being too thick to brush, then wiped off. The thin residual set up to make a slightly waxy surface. Again, I allowed a day or so between coats for curing.
compound cut
             These drawers were complex to build. Since each drawer had a slanted side and front, it required compound cuts to fit them properly. I won't go into the math, here, but I had to spend a couple of hours refreshing myself on trigonometry so I could come up marking dovetailswith formula e to set the compound miter saw to the correct angles. Later, I will post my calculations with a link from here (mainly so I can remember how I did all this next time!). The photo at right shows me finally making a cut with the compound miter saw, which cuts a bevel and a miter at the same time. It was very easy to get confused, so I checked and rechecked before each cut. Once the cutting was done, I laid out the cut lines for the dovetails, which were hand cut. I know of no jig that can cut these dovetails with a router, since they are all cut on beveled pieces, each with a different chopping dovetailbevel angle. Hand cutting was not only necessary, but faster than trying to make some kind of adjustable jig. Thesawing dovetail photo at left shows me making marks for the dovetails, using a marking knife. I also used my 1:8 dovetail marking guide to make the angles of each tail. I marked and cut the tails first, then marked them onto the pins. There is always lively debate whether to cut tails or pins first, but in this case the tails seemed like the easier to cut first and use to mark the pins. At right I am sawing tails withrouting pin waste a Japanese pull saw. This saw cuts a very clean and accurate line and is the only saw I use for dovetails. At left you can see me chopping away the waste between tails (in the side pieces) using a chisel and a guide block. I cleaned up the sides of the tails with a chisel to make sure they were nice and flat, then laid the tail boards (sides of the boards) along the ends of the pin pieces (front and back of the drawer) and used my marking knife to mark the cut lines for the pins. Again, I used my pull saw to cut the pins, then used a router to hog away most of the waste between pins, as seen at right. I used a chisel to cut the base of the pin piece to the correct angle and to smooth the sides and fit the dovetails for a smooth fit.
bottom groove
             After all the tails and pins were cut, I assembled the drawers dry (without glue) and then routed a 1/4" wide groove around the insides for the bottoms to fit into, as seen at right. I took the opportunity, with the drawers dry assembled, to measure for the red cedar bottoms. I made the bottoms by resawing red cedar to 1/2" thickness and edge gluing the pieces to make the large bottom panels. I then cut a rabbet (ledge) around the edge of each of the panels so they would fit into the grooves. The red cedar was used so that the cutting drawer heightdrawers would smell sweet, and I left the cedar unfinished. For the same reason, I pre-finished the insides of the drawer sides and fronts (after disassembling them) with shellac polish. Shellac polish smells nice, and complements theshaping drawer smell of the cedar. After the finishing, I glued up each of the drawers. I don't have a photo of the glue-up, but with all the angles involved there was quite simply a mass of clamps required! With the drawers glued, I spent time fitting them to the unusually shaped drawer pockets. First, I trimmed each drawer to height, allowing a small amount of space for growth when the weather becomes more humid. At left I am making height cuts on the two square faces of the drawer. After that I used a hand plane to match the height on the two angled sides. Then I used a sander with P36 grit (really rough) sandpaper to rough shape the angled sides to the curve they would match, as seen at right. Following the rough shaping I used progressively finer sandpapers until the sides were smooth. It took a long time to fit all the drawers, but once done I finished the sides with shellac (for the same reasons as the insides of the drawers) and finished the fronts with the oil/varnish/beeswax mixes.
bandsaw pull
             I did not mention it earlier, but before gluing up the drawers I drilled holes in the fronts for the drawer pulls shaping pullto attach. The pulls are attached to the fronts with 3/8" dowels. Then to the pulls themselves. I have the routine for making handles down pretty well, so it took little time to cut the blanks to size with all the correct angles and drill holes for the dowels. I then used the bandsaw to cut away the major waste, as seen at right. The handles, starting to take shape, were then shaped using the oscillating spindle sander, as seen at left. Way back I used a whittling knife to shape handles, but after a lot of cut thumbs I realized that the oscillating spindle sander could do the job more safely, less painfully, and a lot faster. Isanding pull bet if the old timers had oscillating spindle sanders, they would have used them, too! The sander enabled me to make the six pulls nearly identical, but I could only get them moderately smooth thisHandle way. I had to do a lot of hand sanding to bring the surfaces to the smoothness I require, so I sat down in the Adirondack chair on the deck and went to sanding, as seen at right. I like to sand this way because the light is so bright I can see the defects and sand them out. I sanded to P600 grit before finishing with shellac polish. The photo at left shows a finished pull attached to a drawer front. All that was left to do was apply some wax to the drawer sides and slide them into the pockets. I installed a strategically placed stop (a neoprene faucet washer screwed in place) to register the drawer faces to the front of the carcase and prevent them pulling out all the way, as well. The stop is screwed into the underside of the top of the drawer pocket after the drawer is inserted half way. I used this method because the drawers are relatively short as drawers go and they are heavy. We don't want them falling out and causing sore toes (or worse)! Below is a photo of the finished piece. Click on this link to see more photos (details and the back of the piece).

2009 No. 3